Orange Charles Flanegan

Notes:

Lorraine Smith Benkelman indicates he was the son of Charles and Cynthia Flanigan:

Listed as Flannigan in the 1870 Census in Cheshire Township with wife Clara, children Oren & Orange age 6 and Albert, Age 2. Listed in 1900 census with wife, Clarissa, daughter Cora, and boarders Anna Walker and Rebecca Angevine. Hiram was Cheshire Township, Allegan County Clerk in the years 1868, 1869, and 1870

Hiram married Clarissa "Cora" Angevine about 1864 in New York. Clarissa (daughter of Samuel B. Angevine and Electa Hayward) was born about 1841 in New York; died on 12 Nov 1911 in Allegan County, Michigan. [Group Sheet] [Family Chart]

Notes:

Lorraine Smith Benkelman shows him as a sibling of Delia and Frank, whereas on some other trees, Delia and Frank are shown as grandchildren of William Angevine and Catherine Sanford, not their children. It is possible, therefore, that Samuel is also a grandson. More research should be done to verify this.

(Research):Census Listings:

1850 Census
New York, Allegany County, Hume
Enumerated 13 Aug 1850
Stamped 323
365-376
Samuel B. Angevine 34 M Farmer Vermont
Electy Angevine 31 F New York
Clarissa Angevine 9 F New York
Rebecca Angevine 7 F New York
Albert Angevine 6 M New York

1860
New York, Allegany County, Post Office Hume
Enumerated 29 Jun 1860
Page 25, stamped 25
211-203
Sam'l Angevine 44 M Farmer $0 $300 Vermont
Electa Angevine 40 F New York
Chloe Angevine 19 F Com. School Teacher New York
Rebecca Angevine 17 F New York
Albert Angevine 15 M New York

1870 Census
Michigan, Allegan County, Township Cheshire
Enumerated 17 June 1870
Pagee 11, Stamped 78
81-82
Angevine, Sandford 45 M WE Farmer $2500 $330 New York
Angevine, Betsey A 27 F W Keeping House Michigan
Angevine, Charles J 1 M W At Home New York
Angevine, Clarence G 1 M W At Home Michigan
83-84
Angevine, Samuel B. 55 M W Farmer $2400 $725 Vermont
Angevine, Electa 52 F W Keeping House New York
Angevine, Rebecca 27 F W At Home New York
Angevine, Albert J 25 M W Works on Farm New York

1880 Census
Michigan, Allegan County, Cheshire
Enumerated June 1880
Page 24 SD 2 ED 22
246-259
Angevine, Samuel W M 63 Farmer Vt NY Vt
Angevine, Rebecca W F 37 Dtr Keeping House NY Vt NY
Walker, Ann W F 36 Servant Domestic Servant NY NY NY
Russell, William Mu M 24 Servant Farm Laborer Indiana
247-260
Angevine, Albert W M 35 Farm Laborer NY Vt NY
Angevine, Ida W F 24 Wife Keeping House Mich NY NY
Hartwell, Nora W F 11 Sister-in-law Mich NY NY
Russell, John Mu M 22 Servant Farm Laborer Indiana

Samuel married Electa Hayward about 1840. Electa was born on 12 Mar 1819 in Otsego County, New York; and died. [Group Sheet] [Family Chart]

Notes:

Evelyn Beran writes that he resided in Poultney, Vermont in 1808, and later removed to Victor, New York.

Lorraine Smith Benkelman, a descendant, shows him as a son of Anthony Angevine and Esther Burr.

William married Catherine Clarissa Sanford about 1808. Catherine (daughter of Oliver Sanford and Phebe Newton) was born about 1787 in Poultney, Rutland County, Vermont; and died. [Group Sheet] [Family Chart]

Notes:

Married:
On the SANFORD-SHULSEN FAMILY tree, Evelyn Beran shows Catherine Sanford and William ANGEVINE as the parents of William and Albert Angevine, and does not list dates or locations of birth for either. Furthermore, she shows that William and an unknown wife were the parents of Delia and Frank Angevine.

Lorraine Smith Benkelman, a descendant, instead shows that William Angevine and Catherine Clarissa Sanford were the parents of Samuel B. Angevine (her ancestor), Delia ANGEVINE and Franks ANGEVINE.

This discrepency should be resolved through further research and documentation.